Legacy Integration Solutions Fail to Meet Expectations
March 17, 2020

Tushar Patel
Cleo

Having an intimate understanding of the exchange of information between suppliers and partners is key when it comes to quickly shifting operations as needed. This crucial knowledge of information flow is best provided by complex integrations between a business' various applications and partners — but doing so is much easier said than done.

Integration is a perennial topic of frustration for enterprise infrastructure — a seemingly never-ending round of "one step forward and two steps back." Why is integration so hard to nail down in your average enterprise? Why is it always a bone of contention among IT staff the world over? The Cleo 2020 State of Ecosystem and Application Integration Report answers those questions, and they are illuminating.

Integration Frustration

The 2020 Report surveyed 305 participants across North America and Europe who design, build and manage applications or infrastructure integrations. One takeaway that dwarfed all the others was a sweeping frustration with the integration status quo.

IT professionals are consistently unhappy with their current integration solutions: 63% say their own legacy integration applications are their biggest challenge. Over half maintain that legacy integration solutions are the problem, while just under half cite having multiple integration solutions.

The High Cost of Poor Integration

It's not just IT's angst fueling the urgency for integration. 30% of respondents say their companies' estimated losses were between $100,000 and $1M per year, while 10% maintain they lose more than $1M per year. Technology issues, data errors, SLA violations — they all add up to a serious problem.

Furthermore, slow onboarding of new partners, customers and suppliers cause 70% of participants to agree that  inefficient processes have a direct impact on productivity. Lost orders are another major source of concern. Just shy of 50% say their company loses more than 50 orders per year, while 17% put that number at 500 orders or more. Each lost order represents lost revenue, and lost confidence in the company that possibly impedes future business.

So, what kind of applications are proving particularly difficult to integrate? The study found that the answer reveals a complex web of applications adding to the complexity of integration:

■ Relational Databases

■ Cloud Storage

■ ERP Applications

■ CRM Applications

■ Finance Applications

■ HCM Applications

■ E-Commerce Applications

■ Marketplace Applications

The problem, of course, is that those applications form the backbone of a modern enterprise's productivity and profitability. When integrating them is an insurmountable challenge, it costs everyone money and, yes, increases frustration.

What's one major item on IT's wish list to wrangle this tangle of application integrations? Automated integration. An impressive 82% of respondents cite automating integration processes as a capability they crave, just behind the 84% who put flexible and highly available integration platforms at the top of the list.


The Full Picture

It's almost ridiculous to think that over 50% of IT staff have limited or no end-to-end visibility into transactions between their systems and those of partners, suppliers and customers, but that's the reality for more than half of companies. How are you supposed to manage and integrate what you can't even see?

That's why 78% of participants say consolidating  disparate integration solutions is a high priority, or possibly Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) modernization. Overall, they see visibility as a critical priority. We've discussed how integration challenges can negatively affect the bottom line, but systems consolidation and EDI modernization can provide a flexible and highly available integration architecture that could enable the end-to-end visibility IT needs to boost productivity and profit.

Ecosystem-Friendly

We've spent our time so far talking about problems — now it's time to talk about new approaches that offer solutions, like ecosystem integration. When we say ecosystem integration, we mean using a single platform for file-based, EDI and application integration to optimize end-to-end integration processes, establishing a dynamic network of partners, applications, suppliers, customers and marketplaces.

The 2020 Report identified ecosystem integration as a hot topic among respondents. An incredible 98% of respondents reported that they would expect to gain substantial benefits and business value from ecosystem integration. Specific benefits cited include cost savings, improved SLAs, happier customers, more efficient order processing, violation reductions and fewer lost orders.

A Modern Approach to Integration

The old way is seldom the best way when it comes to managing enterprise technology complexity. What the 2020 Report told us beyond a doubt is that the old models of opacity, multiple integration vendors, and poor ROI are effectively dead in the water. The integration professionals surveyed in the 2020 Report overwhelmingly want a modern solution that elevates all "flavors" of integration onto one platform, providing comprehensive visibility to speed integration across the enterprise.

Tushar Patel is CMO at Cleo
Share this

Industry News

May 15, 2025

GitLab announced the launch of GitLab 18, including AI capabilities natively integrated into the platform and major new innovations across core DevOps, and security and compliance workflows that are available now, with further enhancements planned throughout the year.

May 15, 2025

Perforce Software is partnering with Siemens Digital Industries Software to transform how smart, connected products are designed and developed.

May 15, 2025

Reply launched Silicon Shoring, a new software delivery model powered by Artificial Intelligence.

May 15, 2025

CIQ announced the tech preview launch of Rocky Linux from CIQ for AI (RLC-AI), an operating system engineered and optimized for artificial intelligence workloads.

May 14, 2025

The Linux Foundation, the nonprofit organization enabling mass innovation through open source, announced the launch of the Cybersecurity Skills Framework, a global reference guide that helps organizations identify and address critical cybersecurity competencies across a broad range of IT job families; extending beyond cybersecurity specialists.

May 14, 2025

CodeRabbit is now available on the Visual Studio Code editor.

The integration brings CodeRabbit’s AI code reviews directly into Cursor, Windsurf, and VS Code at the earliest stages of software development—inside the code editor itself—at no cost to the developers.

May 14, 2025

Chainguard announced Chainguard Libraries for Python, an index of malware-resistant Python dependencies built securely from source on SLSA L2 infrastructure.

May 14, 2025

Sysdig announced the donation of Stratoshark, the company’s open source cloud forensics tool, to the Wireshark Foundation.

May 13, 2025

Pegasystems unveiled Pega Predictable AI™ Agents that give enterprises extraordinary control and visibility as they design and deploy AI-optimized processes.

May 13, 2025

Kong announced the introduction of the Kong Event Gateway as a part of their unified API platform.

May 13, 2025

Azul and Moderne announced a technical partnership to help Java development teams identify, remove and refactor unused and dead code to improve productivity and dramatically accelerate modernization initiatives.

May 13, 2025

Parasoft has added Agentic AI capabilities to SOAtest, featuring API test planning and creation.

May 13, 2025

Zerve unveiled a multi-agent system engineered specifically for enterprise-grade data and AI development.

May 12, 2025

LambdaTest, a unified agentic AI and cloud engineering platform, has announced its partnership with MacStadium(link is external), the industry-leading private Mac cloud provider enabling enterprise macOS workloads, to accelerate its AI-native software testing by leveraging Apple Silicon.

May 12, 2025

Tricentis announced a new capability that injects Tricentis’ AI-driven testing intelligence into SAP’s integrated toolchain, part of RISE with SAP methodology.