Key Benchmarks and Considerations for High-Performing Developer Teams
August 24, 2022

Michael Stahnke

In software delivery, there is no question that speed is important. When software teams move fast, good things happen and business value is delivered more frequently.

But, speed comes with a tradeoff: complexity.

As this complexity grows, how can engineering teams succeed?

After analyzing millions of workflows from more than 50,000 organizations across the world, I've outlined some ways teams can start optimizing their software delivery for high performance.

Identify and Meet These 4 Benchmarks

To help teams optimize their software operations for efficiency, CircleCI's latest State of Software Delivery Report examined more than two years of data from over a quarter of a billion workflows, representing more than 50,000 organizations, to gain insights into the DevOps practices used by software teams globally. As a result, the research identified four key benchmarks that the most successful engineering teams routinely meet:

Throughput: Prioritize being in a state of deploy-readiness state most or all of the time, rather than the number of workflows run.

Duration: Reach workflow durations between five to ten minutes on average.

Mean Time to Recovery: Recover from any failed runs by fixing or reverting in under an hour.

Success Rate: Achieve success rates above 90% for the default branch of an application.

Every software team is different. However, the software delivery patterns observed on our platform, especially the data points from top delivery teams, show key similarities that suggest valuable benchmarks for teams to use as goals.

Now let's break down what these four benchmarks really mean.

The number of workflow runs matters less than being in a deploy-ready state most, if not all, of the time. Rather than the number of workflow runs, the most successful teams prioritize being deploy-ready.

The second item that teams should focus on is Duration, which is the time it takes for a workflow to run. Most successful teams achieve workflow durations of five to ten minutes on average.

Third, Mean Time to Recovery describes what it takes for a workflow to become successful again after a failure has occurred. The data shows teams that recover from failed runs in under an hour are the most resilient.

And finally, Success Rate, which is the number of successful runs divided by the total number of runs over a period of time. The most successful engineering teams achieve success rates above 90%.

Prioritize Team Structure and Culture

Prioritizing team structure and culture is essential to improving software delivery metrics. While the ideal team structure and culture will vary depending on the organizational goals, keeping developers in flow is essential to keeping them as productive as possible. That means scheduling meetings at times that don't conflict with peak productivity hours, which the data shows is between 6 a.m. and 7 a.m. PR on Wednesdays.

It is equally important to determine the number of people on your team. Three out of four of our key metrics show a correlation between larger team size and better engineering performance. The research shows the ideal number of code contributors to aim for is between five and twenty, depending on your team's goals, the scope of your responsibilities, as well as other variables. A larger team is also the best way to avoid burnout, and during a time when developer talent is coveted is especially important to consider.

Test, Test, Test

Regardless of your team size, teams prioritizing test-driven development (TDD) can confidently rely on their tooling during market swings, seasonal fluctuations, and times of uncertainty — such as the pandemic. TDD helps companies ensure bad code gets resolved and that organizations can remain safe and resilient.

TDD includes extensive testing, quality checks, and systems that prevent bad code from being put into production. For example, if bad code gets written into your pipeline, TDD can act as a fail-safe when headcount is low. It's the key to preventing bad code from being put into production and staying competitive, regardless of team size.

Great software delivery is a constant loop, not a linear process. The goal for developer teams isn't to make updates to your application, but to constantly innovate on your software while preventing the introduction of faulty changes. Great developer teams that meet the benchmarks outlined above are key to helping businesses differentiate from their competitors and deliver digital products to consumers as fast as the market demands and as often as it changes.

Michael Stahnke is VP of Platform at CircleCI
Share this

Industry News

December 06, 2023

ngrok unveiled its JavaScript and Python SDKs, enabling developers to programmatically serve their applications and manage traffic by embedding ingress with a single line of code.

December 06, 2023

Data Theorem introduced API Attack Path Visualization capabilities for the protection of APIs and the software supply chain.

December 05, 2023

Security Journey announced support for WCAG, SCIM and continued compliance with SOC2 Type 2, which are leading industry standards.

December 05, 2023

Vercel announced a new suite of features for its Developer Experience (DX) Platform, made for enterprise teams with large codebases.

December 04, 2023

Atlassian Corporation has completed the acquisition of Loom, a video messaging platform that helps users communicate through instantly shareable videos.

December 04, 2023

Orca Security announced that the Orca Cloud Security Platform has achieved the Amazon Web Services (AWS) Built-in Competency.

November 30, 2023

Parasoft, a global leader in automated software testing solutions, today announced complete support for MISRA C++ 2023 with the upcoming release of Parasoft C/C++test 2023.2.

November 30, 2023 achieved the Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (Amazon EKS) Ready designation from Amazon Web Services (AWS).

November 29, 2023

CircleCI implemented a gen2 GPU resource class, leveraging Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (Amazon EC2) G5 instances, offering the latest generation of NVIDIA GPUs and new images tailored for artificial intelligence/machine learning (AI/ML) workflows.

November 29, 2023

XM Cyber announced new capabilities that provide complete and continuous visibility into risks and vulnerabilities in Kubernetes environments.

November 29, 2023

PerfectScale has achieved the Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (Amazon EKS) Ready designation from Amazon Web Services (AWS).

November 28, 2023

BMC announced two new product innovations, BMC AMI DevX Code Insights and BMC AMI zAdviser Enterprise.

November 28, 2023

Rafay Systems announced the availability of the Rafay Cloud Automation Platform — the evolution of its Kubernetes Operations Platform — to enable platform teams to deliver automation and self-service capabilities to developers, data scientists and other cloud users.

November 28, 2023

Bitrise is integrating with Amazon Web Services (AWS) to provide compliance-conscious companies with greater access to CI/CD capabilities for mobile app development.

November 28, 2023

Armory announced a new unified declarative deployment capability for AWS Lambda.